Popular Posts

Saturday, 25 April 2015

Gibraltar's resident warblers - evolution in action


Above: Male Sardinian Warbler

Sardinian Warblers Sylvia melanocephala and Blackcaps S.atricapilla are resident species on the Rock of Gibraltar, a small peninsula at the southern end of Europe, close to North Africa. Although not an island, it seems that isolation of these warblers from mainland populations in Spain has had an effect on their appearance. We studied this in the 1970s and published our findings in 1981.


Above: Male Blackcap (Gibraltar resident form)

We found that Blackcaps were darker in colour than mainland ones and they had shorter, more-rounded wings. We attributed the wing length and shape difference to be due to a combination of two factors: (a) the birds were resident and did not to undertake long migratory journeys and (b) they inhabited dense scrub instead of woodland. Short, rounded, wings are typical of birds that live in dense vegetation. In Gibraltar we also get mainland Blackcaps on passage and wintering. They come all the way from Germany, Belgium, France and the British Isles. This allows us to compare the two directly. Compare the male Blackcaps above and below to see the observable difference.


Above: Male Blackcap (migratory form taken in Gibraltar)

The Sardinian Warblers surprised us. We didn't expect differences from mainland ones which were mainly resident too and occupied many areas nearby. There should be gene flow between them preventing genetic differences accumulating. Yet we found one significant difference: the Gibraltar Sardinian Warblers had significantly longer bills!


Sardinian Warblers at Gibraltar have longer bills than their mainland counterparts. 
Above: male; Below: female


We think the difference is due to character release. The Sardinian Warblers on Gibraltar share the olive scrub only with Blackcaps. On the mainland there are more Sylvia warbler species competing for resources with them. In the absence of these competitors the Sardinian Warblers take a wider range of food items. A longer bill permits them to exploit a wider range of foods. So you don't need to go to Galapagos to see evolution in action!


Above: Female Blackcap (Gibraltar resident form)

If you'd like to read the original paper that we published, just leave us a comment with your email address.

No comments:

Post a Comment